Your fridge just stopped working, and now you have a decision to make—fix it or replace it? Before you start browsing for a new model, let’s break it down: Is a repair worth it, or is your fridge nearing the end of its lifespan?

The answer depends on a few key factors: the age of your fridge, the cost of repair, and whether it’s a quick fix or a long-term investment in a failing unit.

When Repairing Your Refrigerator Makes Sense

It’s Less Than 10 Years Old – Most modern refrigerators are built to last 10 to 20 years, so if yours is on the younger side, a repair can extend its life without significant cost.

The Repair Costs Less Than 50% of a New Unit – If fixing the issue is significantly cheaper than replacing the fridge, repair is usually the smart move.

It’s a Simple Fix – If the problem is something like a broken ice maker, faulty thermostat, or clogged drain line, the cost is manageable, and the repair is relatively quick.

It’s an Energy-Efficient Model – If your fridge is Energy Star-rated and otherwise in good shape, repairing it can save you money over time through lower utility bills.

When It’s Better to Replace Your Refrigerator

It’s Over 20 Years Old – While older refrigerators were often built with more durable components, they are also less energy-efficient. At this age, they tend to require frequent repairs, and newer models will be significantly more efficient in the long run.

The Repair Costs a Fortune – If the sealed system (compressor, evaporator, or condenser) needs replacement, costs start at $800 and can go much higher. With the shift to R600 refrigerant, which meets new energy standards in Europe and other countries, sealed system repairs are often less cost-effective than replacing the unit entirely. R600 is a flammable refrigerant, and while it is considered environmentally friendly, it introduces additional repair complications that make servicing these systems more expensive.

You’ve Had Multiple Repairs Recently – If your fridge has already had two or more repairs in the last few years, it’s likely to keep breaking down. The cost of ongoing maintenance will eventually outweigh the price of a replacement.

Still Not Sure?

A professional diagnosis from a trusted appliance repair expert can help you decide. The last thing you want is to put money into a repair today—only to face another breakdown in a few months.

Need an honest assessment? We’ll walk you through your options and help you make the best choice for your situation.